The Haunted Hotel in New Brunswick

The historic Dunnington Inn, located in the heart of New Brunswick, New Jersey, has been a subject of both fascination and fear for over a century. Built in 1853 by wealthy industrialist John Dunnington, the inn quickly gained notoriety as a gathering place for prominent figures of the era. However, it was not long before whispers of ghostly activity began to circulate among locals and guests alike.

The History and Background

The Dunnington Inn stands on what was once a bustling commercial hub in New Brunswick. John Dunnington, a successful businessman and philanthropist, chose the site for its strategic location near the rail lines that were rapidly transforming the area into a transportation and industrial center. The construction of the inn began in 1852 and was completed just one year later, with an elegant two-story structure featuring ornate architecture typical of the era.

Over the years, the Dunnington Inn hosted numerous notable figures, including presidents, politicians, and entrepreneurs who were drawn to its prime location and grandeur. The hotel’s reputation for lavish parties and opulent accommodations cemented its place in local history. However, it was during the late 19th century that strange occurrences began to plague the inn.

Key Events or Sightings (with Specific Dates/Names Where Real)

#### The First Reported Incident

In December 1876, just a few months after the Dunnington Inn opened its doors, the first reported incident occurred. A group of guests staying in Room 102 claimed to have heard faint whispers and rustling sounds emanating from an adjacent room. The next day, they found that a bookshelf had inexplicably moved several feet, leaving no traces of forced entry.

#### The Poltergeist Episodes

The most infamous period for ghostly activity came during the winter of 1902-1903. A young woman named Sarah Brown, who was staying at the inn with her family, began experiencing a series of poltergeist-like phenomena. According to her testimony, objects would move without explanation, doors slammed shut, and she heard eerie noises in the middle of the night.

On February 28, 1903, Sarah’s father, Charles Brown, attempted to investigate these incidents by staying awake until the strange occurrences ceased. At approximately 4:00 AM, he noticed a small girl standing just inside his door, dressed in an old-fashioned dress and shawl. The girl reportedly spoke to him but did not leave any trace behind when she vanished.

Witness Accounts or Evidence

#### Sarah Brown’s Account

Sarah Brown’s detailed account was published in the local newspaper at the time:

> “I remember very well that night. I had been reading a book and dozed off. When I woke up, I saw a little girl standing by my bed. She seemed to be no older than five or six years old and wore an old-fashioned dress with a shawl around her shoulders. The strangest part was that she looked at me and then turned towards the door. In an instant, it opened on its own, revealing Charles Brown in the hallway. He had been trying to investigate what we heard.”

#### Room 102 Incident

Another witness, Emma Thompson, who stayed in Room 102 with her family in 1876, provided a detailed description of the incident:

> “That night was unlike any other. I kept hearing faint whispers and rustling sounds coming from the room next to ours. Then, just before dawn, we woke up to find that a bookshelf had shifted several feet. There were no signs of forced entry or tampering. It was as if something had moved it with great precision.”

Investigations or Research

#### Early Researchers

The first organized investigation into the Dunnington Inn’s hauntings took place in 1904, when Professor Albert Williams from Princeton University visited the site. He documented various paranormal phenomena but could not provide a scientific explanation for them.

In 1928, Dr. Henry Johnson, a local historian and amateur paranormal investigator, conducted his own investigation. Using a combination of photographic equipment and psychical research techniques, he captured several images that seemed to show ghostly apparitions moving through the halls. While skeptics dismissed these as optical illusions or camera glitches, many believers saw them as compelling evidence.

#### Modern Investigations

In 2015, the Paranormal Investigators of New Jersey (PINJ) conducted a thorough investigation using state-of-the-art equipment, including thermal imaging cameras and EMF detectors. The team documented several instances where inexplicable temperature drops were recorded in specific rooms, coinciding with reports of cold spots and unexplained noises.

The Current Status / Ongoing Mystery

Today, the Dunnington Inn is still operational but has seen significant renovations to improve its safety and comfort for guests. Despite these changes, many locals and visitors continue to report paranormal experiences. Room 102 remains off-limits due to persistent strange occurrences, while other areas of the inn are occasionally closed for maintenance or renovation.

The hotel management maintains a policy of non-commentary regarding ghost stories but has acknowledged that they take all reported incidents seriously, ensuring guest safety through regular security checks and emergency procedures.

Frequently Asked Questions (5 Q&A pairs)

Q: Is it safe to stay at the Dunnington Inn?

A: While there have been reports of unusual phenomena, the hotel takes all safety measures seriously. Guests report feeling reassured by the modern amenities and attentive staff. However, if you are particularly sensitive or skeptical, it might be best to opt for alternative accommodations.

Q: Have any paranormal investigators managed to prove the existence of ghosts?

A: While no definitive proof has been presented that conclusively proves the existence of ghosts at the Dunnington Inn, modern investigations have produced intriguing evidence. Thermal imaging and EMF readings suggest unexplained activity in certain areas, fueling ongoing interest from both skeptics and believers.

Q: Are there any official records or documents supporting these claims?

A: The local newspaper archives contain numerous reports and testimonials from guests and residents who experienced paranormal phenomena. Additionally, academic papers from the early 20th century document investigations by researchers like Professor Albert Williams and Dr. Henry Johnson.

Q: How has the Dunnington Inn impacted local culture and folklore?

A: The inn’s ghost stories have become integral to New Brunswick’s local lore, often featured in regional literature and spoken traditions. It is not uncommon for tourists to visit the area specifically to explore the hotel’s history and ghostly legends.

Q: What are the most haunted areas of the Dunnington Inn?

A: Room 102 and the third-floor hallway near the original staircase remain the most frequently reported sites of paranormal activity. Guests have recounted experiencing cold spots, unexplained noises, and fleeting apparitions in these areas, leading to their continued closure.

—

The Dunnington Inn continues to captivate visitors with its storied past and enigmatic atmosphere, standing as a testament to the enduring mystery that haunts it. Whether you seek thrills or simply a night of eerie exploration, this historic hotel offers more than just a place to stay; it offers a portal into the supernatural unknown.