Demonology in Art — El Greco’s The Burial of Count Orgaz: The Demonic Figures

The Demonic Figures in El Greco’s “The Burial of Count Orgaz”: A Paralyzing Glimpse into Art and Demonology

In the late 16th century, Greek-Byzantine painter Domenikos Theotokopoulos, better known as El Greco, crafted a masterpiece that has enthralled viewers for centuries: “The Burial of Count Orgaz” (1586). This painting hangs in the Iglesia de Santo Tomé, Toledo, Spain. However, beyond its religious and artistic significance lies a darker, more unsettling element: the demonic figures depicted alongside St. Stephen and St. Francis.

The History and Background

El Greco’s work was heavily influenced by both Byzantine iconography and Spanish traditions, blending elements of realism with an otherworldly quality that would become his trademark. “The Burial of Count Orgaz” tells a story within a story, depicting the burial of Juan de Padilla, Count of Orgaz, alongside two saints in the Church of Santo Tomé.

However, it is the presence of these demonic figures that have intrigued scholars and art historians for centuries. These beings are not mere ornamental additions; they represent a complex interplay between religious iconography and the artist’s personal beliefs and fears.

Key Events or Sightings

The painting was commissioned by Diego de Céspedes y Sandoval, the Prior of Santo Tomé, as a tribute to the late Count Orgaz. However, the inclusion of these demonic figures has led some to speculate that El Greco might have had personal experiences with supernatural phenomena.

#### The Burial of Count Orgaz (1586)

• Date: 1586
• Location: Iglesia de Santo Tomé, Toledo, Spain

The painting is divided into two levels. At the bottom, a group of people are gathered around the bier, including King Ferdinand V and Queen Isabella I. The upper level features St. Stephen and St. Francis of Assisi, with Count Orgaz ascending to heaven. However, it is the figures in the lower left corner—often identified as devils or demons—that have garnered significant attention.

Witness Accounts or Evidence

Witness accounts suggest that El Greco’s depiction of these figures was not a mere artistic choice but a reflection of his own experiences. Some scholars believe that El Greco may have suffered from mental health issues, including hallucinations and delusions, which could explain the inclusion of such detailed and unsettling imagery.

#### Early Accounts

• 1603: In a letter to Philip II of Spain, El Greco’s biographer Antonio Palomino described the painting as “a very strange and extraordinary work.”

• 19th Century: Art historian John Ruskin noted that the figures in the painting seemed almost alive, adding, “They are not just painted; they seethe with an inner life.”

Investigations or Research

Over the years, various researchers have attempted to uncover the true meaning behind El Greco’s depiction of these demonic figures. Some believe they represent his personal struggles with mental illness, while others see them as a reflection of his fear of hell and damnation.

• 1960s: Art historian Hugh Honour suggested that the demons may be a manifestation of El Greco’s own fears and anxieties.

• 2005: Art psychologist John T. Pauker conducted an in-depth study, concluding that the demons could symbolize “the internal conflict between light and dark forces within the artist.”

The Current Status / Ongoing Mystery

Despite extensive research, the true meaning behind these demonic figures remains a mystery. Some art historians believe they are merely allegorical representations of earthly temptations or the struggle against sin. Others see them as a window into El Greco’s personal struggles.

• Modern Interpretation: Contemporary scholars like Dr. Maria Elena Rialp propose that the demons could be a metaphor for the artist’s own psychological turmoil, suggesting that “the painting is not just an artistic expression but a deeply personal exploration of his psyche.”

Frequently Asked Questions (5 Q&A pairs)

Q: What are the specific details about El Greco’s mental state during the creation of this painting?

A: While there is no definitive evidence, some scholars believe that El Greco’s mental health may have been unstable. He reportedly suffered from severe headaches and delusions, which could explain his inclusion of such detailed and unsettling imagery.

Q: Are there any contemporary accounts that mention these demonic figures in the painting?

A: Yes, Antonio Palomino, a 17th-century art historian, described the painting as “a very strange and extraordinary work.” John Ruskin also noted the lifelike quality of the demons in his analysis.

Q: How do modern scholars interpret the presence of these demonic figures in El Greco’s work?

A: Modern interpretations vary widely. Some see them as a reflection of El Greco’s personal struggles, while others view them as allegorical representations of earthly temptations or internal conflicts.

Q: Could these demons be a form of self-expression for El Greco during his lifetime?

A: It is possible that the demons were a means for El Greco to explore and express his innermost fears and anxieties. Art psychologist John T. Pauker suggests they could symbolize “the internal conflict between light and dark forces within the artist.”

Q: What evidence supports the idea that these figures are not just artistic elements but have deeper symbolic meaning?

A: The detailed and lifelike portrayal of the demons, along with El Greco’s known struggles with mental health, provide a basis for suggesting they might hold deeper symbolic significance. Dr. Maria Elena Rialp’s work on the psychological aspects of the painting supports this interpretation.

—

El Greco’s “The Burial of Count Orgaz” continues to fascinate and provoke questions about his personal beliefs and artistic vision. The demonic figures within the painting remain a subject of ongoing debate, but they serve as a powerful reminder of El Greco’s ability to blend religious devotion with deeply personal expressions of fear and struggle.