CASE FILE #20295

REPORTED

West Covina Murders and Supernatural Claims

  • 2026
  • 4 min read
  • possession cases - modern

The West Covina Murders and Supernatural Claims

In February 1984, a series of horrific murders shook West Covina, California, leaving investigators baffled by their nature and origin. Four people were found dead in three separate homes within just two days, with each murder scene displaying disturbing similarities. As police struggled to make sense of the gruesome crimes, local residents began to whisper about supernatural forces at work.

The History and Background

West Covina is a city located east of Los Angeles in Southern California. Known for its suburban charm and tight-knit community, the murders struck a chord that extended beyond the immediate victims’ families. The case gained national attention, with many local residents and even some law enforcement officials attributing the killings to paranormal phenomena.

Key Events or Sightings

#### February 21, 1984: The First Murder

On February 21, 1984, the body of Jennifer Babbitt was discovered in her home on North Central Avenue. She had been bludgeoned with a hammer and stabbed multiple times. Her husband, David Babbitt, was found dead just two miles away later that day.

#### February 23, 1984: The Second Murder

On the following Tuesday, February 23, police received a call about a woman’s body in another North Central Avenue home. This time, the victim was identified as Nancy Lafferty, who had also been bludgeoned with a hammer and stabbed.

#### February 25, 1984: The Third Murder

The third and final murder occurred on Thursday, February 25. This time, the body of Susan Babbitt, David’s sister, was found in her home. Her death paralleled those of Jennifer and Nancy with a hammer blow and stabbing.

Witness Accounts or Evidence

Residents reported strange occurrences around the time of these murders. One eyewitness described seeing a woman dressed in white running from one of the homes on the night of February 23. Another claimed to have heard eerie noises coming from the area just before the murders were discovered. Some locals also recounted seeing unexplained lights and shadows moving in the vicinity.

The Babbitt family, particularly David’s wife Jennifer, had a history of paranormal experiences. She was known to communicate with spirits and even claimed to have recorded conversations with them on tape. While some dismissed her claims as delusions or self-hypnosis, others believed they provided insight into what may have occurred during the murders.

Investigations or Research

The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department launched a thorough investigation but found no clear motive for the killings. Fingerprint evidence and DNA testing did not reveal any connections between the victims or their attackers. Police even considered the possibility of multiple assailants working in tandem, but this theory was eventually discarded as implausible.

A series of séances were conducted to try and communicate with the spirits believed responsible for the murders. None provided any useful information, leading investigators to rule out supernatural causes entirely.

The Current Status / Ongoing Mystery

Despite extensive investigations, the West Covina Murders remain unsolved. The cases continue to intrigue criminologists and paranormal enthusiasts alike. Some believe that the victims were targeted due to their spiritual beliefs or practices, while others maintain that a supernatural entity was responsible for the killings.

Local legends persist, with some residents claiming that the Babbitts’ house continues to be haunted by malevolent spirits. Every year, locals gather at the site of the murders to share stories and offer tributes, adding to the enduring mystery surrounding these tragic events.

Frequently Asked Questions (5 Q&A pairs)

Q: Were the West Covina Murders ever solved?

A: No, the murders remain unsolved. The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department investigated thoroughly but found no conclusive evidence pointing to a single suspect or motive. While some theories suggested supernatural involvement, they were not substantiated by official investigations.

Q: Did any paranormal activity occur during the investigation?

A: Reports of strange occurrences and unexplained phenomena persisted throughout the investigation. However, these claims have neither been confirmed nor refuted by law enforcement officials. The majority of investigators remained skeptical about their validity.

Q: Are there any ongoing efforts to solve the case?

A: There are no official efforts currently underway to revisit or solve the West Covina Murders. However, the case continues to attract interest from paranormal researchers and enthusiasts who occasionally attempt to uncover new leads or evidence through private investigations.

Q: Why do some people believe in supernatural involvement in the murders?

A: Some residents and investigators maintain that the similarity of the attacks and the victims’ spiritual background suggest a supernatural element. Claims of strange noises, unexplained lights, and paranormal experiences further fuel these beliefs among local communities.

Q: Are there any legal implications for the family involved in the case?

A: The Babbitt family members are not facing any legal consequences related to the murders. While Jennifer had a history of paranormal claims, there is no evidence linking her or anyone else within the household to the killings directly.

Leave a Reply